Thursday 6 December 2012

Carnegie Longlist, one month in.

The long list was announced on the 5th November, see my post for the whole list as well as which I had already read.  As I did last year, I'd like to read all of them before the shortlist is announced, so here's an update on my progress...I've not only been reading Carnegie books but I only mention those listed here (check my mini-reviews on Twitter or find me on Goodreads to see what else I've read).  They've all been good but not amazing:

The No.1 Car Spotter and the Firebird by Atinuke - really nice but not enough for Carnegie
Jasmine Skies by Sita Brahmachari - found the story dull but enjoyed the descriptions of India
Dead Time by Anne Cassidy - pretty good but tried to fit too much in
A Greyhound of a Girl by Roddy Doyle - lovely tale but not quite Carnegie worthy
The Things We Did For Love by Natasha Farrant - very moving story of life in occupied France, again just not quite literary enough
Hero on a Bicycle by Shirley Hughes - can see this being made into a film, a really good book that could well end up on the official short just won't be on mine!
Hitler's Angel by William Osborne - too predictable but with some excellent moments
Goblins by Philip Reeve - very funny
The Sleeping Army by Francesca Simon - didn't grip me but isn't terrible

Except for one that that is so brilliant that it has to replace one of my initial personal shortlist:
VIII by H.M. Castor
I'm not sure it is a winner though, and I won't tell you which it replaced - you'll have to wait until March for my final list!
Is it just the ones I happen to have picked up so far, or are there are heck of a lot of war books on the list?  I really need to read something to cheer me up but have nothing with a happy blurb on my TBR pile!

1 comment:

  1. I'll have to dig out VIII again - I think I started reading it with my ex-Historian hat on and forgot to read it as a kidlit enthusiast :) The ex-Historian hat insists on being cynical at all times - it's not a happy hat unless it's being cynical about something, I really must leave it on the shelf for longer! :p